What Doctors in Carmel, Cleveland Have Seen That Science Can't Explain

The phenomenon of clocks stopping at the moment of death—reported by families, nurses, and even physicians—persists in the folklore of hospitals in Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee and beyond. While skeptics attribute this to confirmation bias (we notice stopped clocks only when someone dies), "Physicians' Untold Stories" by Dr. Scott Kolbaba presents accounts in which the clock-stopping phenomenon occurred in conjunction with other anomalies—electronic equipment failing, call lights activating, and staff independently reporting sensing the moment of death from other parts of the hospital. This clustering of anomalies is difficult to explain through confirmation bias alone, as it requires multiple independent observers to simultaneously experience the same bias about different phenomena. For readers in Carmel, Cleveland, these clustered accounts transform a familiar folk belief into a legitimate subject of inquiry.

Dr. Scott Kolbaba

About the Author

Dr. Scott J. Kolbaba, MD is an internist at Northwestern Medicine in Wheaton, Illinois. He interviewed more than 200 physicians about their most extraordinary experiences.

Book cover

Physicians' Untold Stories

by Scott J. Kolbaba, MD4.5 stars (1018 reviews)

Miraculous experiences doctors are hesitant to share with their patients, or ANYONE!

Order on Amazon →

Dr. Kolbaba interviewed 200 courageous physicians who came forward with 26 of the most miraculous experiences of their careers.

🔬

Medical Fact

Surgeons used to operate in their street clothes. Surgical scrubs weren't introduced until the 1940s.

Physician Burnout & Wellness Near Carmel, Cleveland

Physicians practicing in Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee work at the intersection of modern medicine and experiences that resist explanation. In conversations that rarely leave the break room or the on-call suite, doctors in and around Carmel, Cleveland have reported encounters with phenomena that their training never prepared them for — from patients who describe verifiable details about events that occurred while they were clinically dead, to deathbed visions shared simultaneously by multiple family members, to recoveries that defy every prognostic model available.

The medical community in Carmel, Cleveland includes physicians across every stage of their careers — residents navigating the exhaustion of training, mid-career practitioners balancing clinical demands with family life, and veteran physicians carrying decades of experiences that challenge the boundaries of conventional medicine. Burnout touches all of them differently, but a common thread runs through: the desire to remember why they chose medicine in the first place, and the rare but profound moments that remind them.

Physician Burnout by Specialty

Percentage reporting at least one symptom (Medscape, 2024)

🔬

Medical Fact

The phrase "stat" used in hospitals comes from the Latin "statim," meaning "immediately."

Physician Wellness, Grief & Finding Meaning Near Carmel, Cleveland

The Southeast's church fan—a flat cardboard paddle with a funeral home advertisement on one side and Jesus on the other—is an unlikely symbol of healing near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee. But in un-air-conditioned churches where summer services can cause heat-related illness, the church fan is preventive medicine. And the act of fanning a sick neighbor during a long sermon is a gesture of care that no medical textbook includes but every Southern nurse recognizes.

The Southeast's military families near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee carry a healing tradition forged in wartime: the knowledge that recovery is not a return to normal but a construction of something new. Spouses who've watched their partners rebuild after deployment injuries know that healing is an active process—it requires patience, adaptation, and the willingness to love a person who is different from the one who left.

🔬

Medical Fact

The first successful blood transfusion was performed in 1818 by James Blundell, a British obstetrician.

Faith, Medicine & the Unexplained in Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee

The Southeast's growing 'nones'—people claiming no religious affiliation near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee—still live in a culture so saturated with faith that they absorb its medical implications by osmosis. Even secular Southerners tend to view illness through a moral lens, describe recovery in terms of grace, and approach death with more spiritual openness than their counterparts in other regions. The Bible Belt's influence extends beyond the pews.

The Southern tradition of 'prayer warriors'—congregants specifically designated to pray for the sick near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee—creates a spiritual support network that parallels the medical one. Studies conducted at Southern medical centers have shown that patients who know they're being prayed for report lower anxiety scores, regardless of the prayers' metaphysical efficacy. The knowledge of being held in someone's spiritual attention is itself therapeutic.

💡

Did You Know?

The Nightingale Pledge, recited by nursing graduates, was composed in 1893 — a modified version of the Hippocratic Oath.

Ghost Stories and the Supernatural Near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee

Spanish moss draping the live oaks outside Southern hospitals near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee creates an atmosphere that exists nowhere else in American medicine. The filtered light, the humid stillness, the sense of time moving at a different speed—these environmental qualities make the Southeast's hospital ghost stories feel less like interruptions of reality and more like natural extensions of it. The South has always been haunted; its hospitals simply concentrate the phenomenon.

Gullah Geechee communities along the Southeast coast near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee maintain a relationship with the spirit world that is both matter-of-fact and medically relevant. 'Haints' are addressed directly, negotiated with, and accommodated—not feared. When a Gullah patient tells their physician that a haint is sitting on their chest causing breathing problems, the culturally competent response isn't a psychiatric referral; it's an albuterol inhaler and a respectful acknowledgment.

Types of Phenomena in the Book

Distribution across 26 physician accounts

💡

Did You Know?

Dr. Kolbaba found that many physicians' stories involved patients who predicted their own death — sometimes down to the hour.

Cleveland: Where History, Medicine, and the Supernatural Converge

Cleveland's most famous haunted site is Franklin Castle, a brooding Victorian Gothic mansion with a history of mysterious deaths. Hannes Tiedemann, the original owner, lost several family members under unusual circumstances, and rumors of hidden rooms containing skeletons—partially confirmed when human bones were found in a hidden chamber in the 1970s—have fueled the castle's terrifying reputation. The castle has changed hands numerous times, with each owner reporting violent paranormal activity and ultimately abandoning the property. Squire's Castle, the roofless stone gatehouse in the Metroparks, generates stories of Rebecca Squire's ghost seen carrying a lantern through the empty structure. Cleveland's Lake Erie waterfront adds to the city's eerie atmosphere, with stories of ghostly ships and drowned sailors in the Great Lakes tradition. The city's abandoned industrial sites—remnants of its steel and manufacturing past—contribute to an urban gothic landscape that fuels supernatural storytelling.

Cleveland is a global capital of cardiac medicine, primarily through the Cleveland Clinic, which has been ranked the number one heart program in the United States for over 25 consecutive years. The Clinic was founded in 1921 by four physicians who had served together in World War I, and its group practice model became influential in American healthcare. In 1967, Cleveland Clinic surgeon Dr. René Favaloro performed the first coronary artery bypass graft surgery, revolutionizing the treatment of heart disease and saving millions of lives worldwide. The Cleveland Clinic has continued to innovate, performing the first near-total face transplant in the US in 2008. Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, one of the top research-oriented medical schools in the country, has made major contributions to biomedical research, particularly in the study of Alzheimer's disease, cancer, and genetic medicine.

💡

Did You Know?

The tradition of physicians wearing white coats began in the late 1800s to symbolize cleanliness and scientific authority.

Watch Dr. Kolbaba Share These Stories

📖

About the Book

The stories in the book are told in the physicians' own words — Dr. Kolbaba prioritized preserving their authentic voices.

Notable Locations in Cleveland

Franklin Castle: This imposing 1881 Victorian Gothic mansion in the Ohio City neighborhood, built by German immigrant Hannes Tiedemann, is considered the most haunted house in Ohio, with reports of crying babies, ghostly children, and a woman in black connected to mysterious family deaths.

Squire's Castle: This stone shell in the North Chagrin Reservation was built in the 1890s as a gatehouse for a mansion never completed, reputedly haunted by the ghost of Feargus Squire's wife Rebecca, who allegedly died inside.

The Agora Theatre: This 1913 theater has a reputation for ghostly encounters, including sightings of a woman in period clothing in the balcony, believed to be connected to the building's history as a vaudeville house.

Cleveland Clinic: Founded in 1921, it is consistently ranked among the top hospitals in the world, particularly renowned for its cardiac care program, which has been ranked #1 in the nation for over 25 consecutive years.

University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center: A major teaching hospital affiliated with Case Western Reserve University, known for its pioneering work in pediatric medicine and emergency care since its founding in 1866.

📖

About the Book

Dr. Kolbaba chose to interview only practicing physicians — not retired doctors — to ensure stories were fresh and detailed.

Medical Heritage in Tennessee

Tennessee is home to some of the most influential medical institutions in the American South. Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, established in 1874, has been a leader in cardiac surgery, pharmacogenomics, and health informatics—its Biomedical Informatics program pioneered electronic health records. The University of Tennessee Health Science Center in Memphis, founded in 1911, operates alongside the famed St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, established in 1962 by entertainer Danny Thomas with the mission that no child should be denied treatment based on ability to pay. St. Jude has achieved a childhood cancer survival rate exceeding 80%, up from 20% when it opened.

Meharry Medical College in Nashville, founded in 1876, is the nation's oldest and largest historically Black medical school, having trained approximately half of all African American physicians and dentists in the country by the mid-20th century. Tennessee's medical history also includes the Body Farm at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville—officially the Anthropological Research Facility, founded by Dr. William Bass in 1981—where donated human remains decompose under various conditions to advance forensic science. The East Tennessee State University Quillen College of Medicine addresses healthcare needs in the Appalachian region, one of the most medically underserved areas in the nation.

Reader Ratings Distribution

Based on 1,018 Goodreads ratings

📊

Research Finding

A study of ICU workers found that debriefing sessions after patient deaths reduced PTSD symptoms by 40%.

Supernatural Folklore and Ghost Traditions in Tennessee

Tennessee is home to the Bell Witch legend, one of the most famous hauntings in American history. Beginning in 1817 in Adams, Tennessee, the Bell family reported a malicious entity that physically assaulted family members, spoke in multiple voices, and tormented patriarch John Bell until his death in 1820. The Bell Witch is the only case in American history where a spirit is credited in local lore with killing a person. Even Andrew Jackson reportedly visited the Bell farm and was so disturbed by the experience that he declared he would rather fight the British than face the Bell Witch again.

The Orpheum Theatre in Memphis, built in 1928, is haunted by the ghost of a 12-year-old girl named Mary, who was killed by a streetcar outside the theater in the 1920s. Staff and performers report seeing a girl in a white dress sitting in seat C-5, which is always left empty in her honor. In Knoxville, the Baker Peters Jazz Club on Kingston Pike is housed in a Civil War-era mansion where Confederate Colonel Abner Baker killed his neighbor John Peters in a dispute; both men's ghosts are said to haunt the building, with cold spots, flying objects, and apparitions reported by staff and patrons.

📊

Research Finding

Patients who view nature scenes during recovery from surgery require 25% less pain medication than those facing a blank wall.

Haunted Hospitals and Medical Landmarks in Tennessee

Eastern State Hospital (Knoxville): The Eastern State Psychiatric Hospital in Knoxville, operating from 1886, treated thousands of patients with mental illness over its history. The older buildings, some now demolished, were associated with reports of screaming from empty wards, lights flickering in unoccupied rooms, and the ghost of a woman in white seen walking the grounds near the patient cemetery.

Old South Pittsburgh Hospital (South Pittsburg): The Old South Pittsburgh Hospital, which closed in 1998 after decades of service to the small town, is now operated as a paranormal investigation venue. Visitors have documented shadow figures, disembodied voices, and a full-body apparition of a nurse in the operating room. One of the most frequently reported phenomena is the ghost of an elderly man seen sitting in a wheelchair on the second floor.

Over 200 physicians interviewed. 26 of the most miraculous experiences of their careers, chronicled in one book.

Physicians' Untold Stories

How This Book Can Help You

Tennessee's extraordinary medical landscape—from St. Jude Children's Research Hospital's work with dying children to Vanderbilt's cutting-edge cardiac surgery to the University of Tennessee's Body Farm studying death itself—makes the state a natural setting for the kind of boundary-crossing clinical experiences Dr. Kolbaba recounts in Physicians' Untold Stories. Physicians at Meharry Medical College, the nation's oldest historically Black medical school, have long understood that healing encompasses dimensions beyond the purely physical—a perspective that aligns with Dr. Kolbaba's observations at Northwestern Medicine, where his Mayo Clinic training met the unexplainable realities of the dying process.

Veterans near Carmel, Cleveland, Tennessee who read this book may find echoes of their own experiences. Combat produces extraordinary perceptions—visions of fallen comrades, premonitions of danger, sensations of being guided by unseen forces—that share features with the clinical experiences described in these pages. The book validates a category of experience that military culture, like medical culture, has traditionally silenced.

Physicians' Untold Stories book cover — by Dr. Scott J. Kolbaba, MD

Reader Ratings Distribution

Based on 1,018 Goodreads ratings

Sometimes all we need to do is believe. — From the introduction to Physicians' Untold Stories

Physicians' Untold Stories

Free Interactive Wellness Tools

Explore our physician-designed assessment tools — free, private, and educational.

Other Neighborhoods in Cleveland

Nearby Cities

Explore Other Countries

Related Reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Discover the Stories Medicine Never Says Out Loud

Physicians' Untold Stories by Scott J. Kolbaba, MD4.5 stars from 1018 readers.

Order on Amazon →

This page contains approximately 1,947 words of unique content.

Physicians' Untold Stories by Dr. Scott Kolbaba

Amazon Bestseller

The Stories Medicine Never Told You

Over 200 physicians interviewed. 26 true stories of ghost encounters, near-death experiences, and miraculous recoveries that will change the way you think about life, death, and what lies beyond.

By Dr. Scott J. Kolbaba, MD — 4.5★ from 1,018 ratings on Goodreads