Physicians Near Jihlava Break Their Silence

When Barbara Cummiskey was diagnosed with progressive multiple sclerosis, her physicians in the Midwest prepared her and her family for a future of increasing disability. Over years, the disease followed its predicted course with devastating precision. Cummiskey lost the ability to walk, then to stand, then to breathe independently. She was placed on a ventilator, and her medical team documented extensive brain lesions on MRI — the kind of damage that neurologists in Jihlava and everywhere recognize as irreversible.

Then, in a moment that stunned everyone who witnessed it, Cummiskey got up from her bed, removed her own ventilator, and walked. Subsequent MRI scans showed that her brain lesions had vanished entirely. Her neurologists had no explanation. In "Physicians' Untold Stories," Dr. Scott Kolbaba presents Cummiskey's case not as an argument for any particular belief but as a fact — a documented, verified, medically inexplicable fact that challenges everything physicians in Jihlava, Moravia have been taught about the limits of neurological recovery. Her story remains one of the most extraordinary in the book and in the annals of modern medicine.

Researchers have long noted that spontaneous remission of cancer appears to occur more frequently in certain tumor types — renal cell carcinoma, neuroblastoma, melanoma, and certain lymphomas — than in others. This observation, while not fully explained, suggests that biological factors play a role in these remissions and that they are not purely random events. Some researchers hypothesize that these tumor types may be particularly immunogenic, making them more susceptible to immune-mediated regression.

Dr. Scott Kolbaba's "Physicians' Untold Stories" includes cases spanning multiple tumor types, some consistent with this immunogenicity hypothesis and others that challenge it. For oncology researchers in Jihlava, Moravia, these accounts add valuable anecdotal evidence to the growing case for systematic study of spontaneous remission. Understanding why certain tumors regress spontaneously could revolutionize cancer treatment — transforming what is currently a medical mystery into a therapeutic strategy.

The hospice and palliative care providers of Jihlava walk with patients and families through the most difficult passages of life. They know that death is not always the end of the story — that some patients who enter hospice care with terminal diagnoses experience unexpected improvements that return them to active life. "Physicians' Untold Stories" documents several such cases, reminding palliative care providers in Jihlava, Moravia that their work, focused as it is on comfort and dignity, sometimes unfolds in a context where the impossible becomes real. For these dedicated professionals, Dr. Kolbaba's book is both a source of wonder and a validation of the profound, unpredictable nature of the work they do.

The ethical dimensions of miraculous recovery in medicine are seldom discussed but deeply important. When a patient recovers from a terminal illness without medical explanation, questions arise about how to document the case, how to communicate with the patient, and how to integrate the experience into clinical practice. Should the physician attribute the recovery to an unknown medical process? Should they acknowledge the possibility of divine intervention? Should they modify their approach to other patients based on what they witnessed?

Dr. Kolbaba's "Physicians' Untold Stories" reveals that physicians in Jihlava, Moravia and across the country navigate these ethical questions largely without guidance. Medical education does not prepare doctors for the experience of witnessing an inexplicable recovery, and medical ethics curricula do not address the unique challenges these cases present. Kolbaba's book begins to fill this gap by modeling an approach grounded in honesty, humility, and respect for both the patient's experience and the limits of medical knowledge.

Research published in Acta Oncologica documents spontaneous cancer remission occurring in approximately 1 in 60,000 to 100,000 cancer patients — full regression without treatment or with treatment considered inadequate. For oncologists in Jihlava, these cases represent medicine's greatest mystery: the body's unexplained capacity to heal itself against impossible odds.

The Institute of Noetic Sciences' Spontaneous Remission Project, compiled by Brendan O'Regan and Caryle Hirshberg, catalogued 3,500 references to spontaneous remission from the medical literature across more than 800 journals. The database includes cases of remission from nearly every type of cancer, including advanced metastatic disease with documented distant metastases. The consistency of these cases across cancer types, patient demographics, and geographic locations suggests that spontaneous remission is not a random error in diagnosis but a genuine biological phenomenon whose mechanism remains unknown.

In oncology wards across Jihlava, physicians regularly counsel patients about survival statistics — the five-year rates, the median survival times, the probability curves that shape treatment decisions. These statistics are invaluable tools, grounded in decades of research and thousands of patient outcomes. Yet Dr. Scott Kolbaba's "Physicians' Untold Stories" reminds us that statistics describe populations, not individuals, and that within every dataset there exist outliers whose outcomes no curve can predict.

The patients in Kolbaba's book are these outliers. They are the ones whose cancers disappeared, whose tumors shrank spontaneously, whose terminal diagnoses were followed not by death but by complete recovery. For oncologists in Jihlava, Moravia, these cases represent a challenge not to abandon statistical thinking but to supplement it — to hold space for the possibility that individual patients may access healing pathways that population-level data cannot capture. This is not a rejection of evidence-based medicine but an expansion of it.

The field of psychoneuroimmunology (PNI) has established multiple pathways through which psychological states influence immune function. The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis mediates stress-induced immunosuppression through cortisol release. The sympathetic nervous system directly innervates lymphoid organs, allowing the brain to modulate immune cell activity in real time. Neuropeptides and neurotransmitters, including endorphins and serotonin, have been shown to affect lymphocyte proliferation, natural killer cell activity, and cytokine production. These findings provide a biological basis for understanding how mental and emotional states can influence physical health.

Dr. Kolbaba's "Physicians' Untold Stories" documents recoveries that may represent extreme manifestations of these PNI pathways — cases where profound psychological or spiritual experiences coincided with dramatic immune system activation and tumor regression. While the book does not make specific mechanistic claims, it provides clinical observations that PNI researchers in Jihlava, Moravia may find valuable. If moderate changes in psychological state can measurably affect immune function — as PNI has demonstrated — then the profound psychological transformations described by patients who experienced spontaneous remission may produce proportionally more profound immunological effects. Testing this hypothesis would require prospective studies of patients who report transformative spiritual experiences, with serial immune function monitoring — studies that Kolbaba's case collection helps to justify and design.

The concept of salutogenesis, introduced by medical sociologist Aaron Antonovsky in the 1970s, shifts the focus of medical inquiry from pathogenesis (the origins of disease) to salutogenesis (the origins of health). Antonovsky argued that traditional medicine asks the wrong question — "Why do people get sick?" — when it should be asking, "Why do people stay healthy?" or, more provocatively, "Why do some people recover from conditions that should be fatal?" His concept of "sense of coherence" — the feeling that one's life is comprehensible, manageable, and meaningful — emerged as a central predictor of health outcomes across diverse populations and conditions.

Dr. Kolbaba's "Physicians' Untold Stories" can be read as a contribution to salutogenic research, documenting cases that illustrate the extreme end of the health-generating spectrum. Many of the patients whose recoveries are documented in the book exhibited precisely the qualities Antonovsky identified as health-promoting: a strong sense of coherence, deep social connections, clear sense of purpose, and active engagement with their own healing process. For public health researchers in Jihlava, Moravia, the intersection of salutogenesis and spontaneous remission offers a framework for understanding how psychological and social factors might contribute to even the most dramatic healing outcomes.