
The Untold Stories of Medicine Near Carmel, Rochester
The STEP trial, published in the American Heart Journal in 2006, was the largest and most rigorously designed study of intercessory prayer ever conducted. Its finding that prayer showed no significant benefit — and that patients who knew they were being prayed for actually fared slightly worse — was widely reported as definitive proof that prayer does not work. Yet Dr. Scott Kolbaba's "Physicians' Untold Stories" reminds us that clinical trials capture averages, not individuals, and that the most profound effects of prayer may resist the standardization that clinical trials require. For readers in Carmel, Rochester, New York, this book offers a necessary counterpoint to the STEP trial's headline results, presenting individual cases where prayer appeared to make a difference that no trial could capture.

Medical Fact
The first successful blood transfusion was performed in 1818 by James Blundell, a British obstetrician.
Physician Burnout & Wellness Near Carmel, Rochester
Carmel, Rochester's healthcare landscape reflects broader patterns in New York's medical system — the pressures of modern practice, the isolation that comes from witnessing extraordinary events without a framework to discuss them, and the gradual erosion of meaning that drives so many physicians toward burnout. Yet it is precisely in communities like Carmel, Rochester that the unexplained tends to surface most vividly, in moments that practicing physicians remember for the rest of their careers.
Physicians practicing in Carmel, Rochester, New York work at the intersection of modern medicine and experiences that resist explanation. In conversations that rarely leave the break room or the on-call suite, doctors in and around Carmel, Rochester have reported encounters with phenomena that their training never prepared them for — from patients who describe verifiable details about events that occurred while they were clinically dead, to deathbed visions shared simultaneously by multiple family members, to recoveries that defy every prognostic model available.
Medical Fact
The femur (thighbone) is the longest and strongest bone in the human body.
Ghost Stories and the Supernatural Near Carmel, Rochester, New York
Penn Station, Grand Central, and the great train terminals of the Northeast once served as makeshift hospitals during epidemics. Their modern replacements near Carmel, Rochester, New York sometimes inherit more than real estate. Transit workers and commuters have reported seeing nurses in white moving purposefully through crowds that part around them—crowds that, when questioned, saw nothing at all.
Brownstone hospitals converted from 19th-century townhouses dot the older neighborhoods of Carmel, Rochester, New York. These buildings remember every patient who ever crossed their thresholds. Night-shift workers describe hearing the creak of a rocking chair in rooms that contain no rocking chair, and the laughter of children in pediatric wards that have been closed for decades.
Types of Phenomena in the Book
Distribution across 26 physician accounts
Medical Fact
The first CT scan was performed on a patient in 1971 at Atkinson Morley Hospital in London.
Near-Death Experiences Reported by Physicians Near Carmel, Rochester
The AWARE II study, an expansion of Parnia's original work across multiple Northeast hospitals near Carmel, Rochester, New York, uses tablet computers mounted on shelves to display random images during resuscitation attempts. The study's genius is its simplicity: if a patient reports the correct image during a verified period of cardiac arrest, the implications are unambiguous. No neurochemical theory can explain accurate visual perception from a flatlined brain.
The Northeast's aging population means that physicians in Carmel, Rochester, New York are managing more end-of-life cases than ever before. Hospice nurses in the region report that patients who've had prior NDEs approach death with markedly less anxiety—a clinical observation that aligns with Greyson's published data showing reduced death anxiety in NDE experiencers, sometimes persisting for decades after the event.
Did You Know?
The tradition of physicians wearing white coats began in the late 1800s to symbolize cleanliness and scientific authority.
Watch Dr. Kolbaba Discuss These Stories
Did You Know?
Ancient Babylonian physicians could be executed for surgical errors — medical malpractice law has deep roots.

Dr. Scott J. Kolbaba, MD
Northwestern Medicine internist. University of Illinois College of Medicine. Mayo Clinic residency. 200+ physician interviews.
"I shivered. I cried. I read some out loud to the spouse. Please write more." — Amazon Review
Did You Know?
Dr. Kolbaba has said that writing the book taught him more about being a physician than his entire medical education.
Physician Wellness, Grief & Finding Meaning Near Carmel, Rochester
Northeast hospitals near Carmel, Rochester, New York have chapels, meditation rooms, and gardens that exist for a single purpose: to remind patients, families, and staff that healing has a dimension that medicine cannot measure. These quiet spaces—often tucked into corners, easy to overlook—are where the most important conversations happen. Not between doctor and patient, but between a person and whatever they hold sacred.
Rural medicine in the Northeast doesn't get the attention that metropolitan medical centers receive, but physicians in small towns near Carmel, Rochester, New York practice a form of healing that no academic center can replicate. They know their patients by name, by family, by the thirty years of medical history they carry in their heads. This longitudinal intimacy is itself therapeutic—being truly known is a form of care.
About the Book
The book has been discussed in medical ethics courses as an example of physicians' inner lives beyond clinical practice.
Death, Grief, and Cultural Traditions in New York
New York's death customs are as diverse as its population. In the Hasidic Jewish communities of Brooklyn, chevra kadisha (burial societies) prepare the body through ritual washing (tahara) and dress it in simple white shrouds (tachrichim), with burial required within 24 hours. In Chinatown, traditional Chinese funerals feature burning joss paper and hell money at the funeral home, with mourners wearing white and a brass band leading the funeral procession through Mulberry Street. Upstate, in the rural communities of the Hudson Valley and Adirondacks, the tradition of neighbors gathering to dig the grave by hand persisted well into the 20th century, accompanied by church bell tolling and hymn singing at the graveside.
Physician Burnout by Specialty
Percentage reporting at least one symptom (Medscape, 2024)
Research Finding
Reading narrative-based accounts of patient experiences has been shown to improve physician empathy scores by 15-20%.
Medical Heritage in New York
New York has been the epicenter of American medicine since the colonial era. The Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons, established in 1767 as the medical faculty of King's College, is the oldest medical school in the state. Bellevue Hospital Center in Manhattan, tracing its origins to 1736, is the oldest public hospital in the United States and pioneered America's first ambulance service in 1869, first maternity ward, and first cardiac catheterization. NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital, formed by the 1998 merger of Columbia-Presbyterian and New York Hospital-Cornell, consistently ranks among the top hospitals in the world.
The state's contributions to medicine are staggering in scope. Dr. Jonas Salk developed the polio vaccine at the University of Pittsburgh but was born and educated in New York City, and the first mass polio vaccinations took place in New York in 1955. Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, founded in 1884, became the world's preeminent cancer hospital. The New York Blood Center pioneered modern blood banking. Mount Sinai Hospital, founded in 1852, was one of the first hospitals to accept patients regardless of race, religion, or ability to pay. Upstate, the University of Rochester Medical Center and the Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center in Buffalo have made foundational contributions to ophthalmology and oncology respectively.
Research Finding
Art therapy in healthcare settings has been associated with reductions in depression, anxiety, and pain across multiple studies.
Haunted Hospitals and Medical Landmarks in New York
Willard Asylum for the Chronic Insane (Willard): Willard Asylum operated from 1869 to 1995 in the Finger Lakes region, housing patients who were considered incurable. After closure, over 400 suitcases belonging to former patients were discovered in an attic, their contents forming a haunting archive of lives interrupted. Staff reported seeing ghostly figures near Willard's lakeside cemetery, where thousands of patients were buried in numbered graves.
Old Bellevue Hospital Morgue (Manhattan): Bellevue Hospital's old morgue in the basement of the original 26th Street building processed thousands of bodies over more than a century. Morgue workers over the decades reported bodies that appeared to shift position overnight, unexplained temperature drops, and the sound of whispered conversations in the cold storage rooms when no living person was present.
“Dr. Kolbaba is bringing his message of spiritual love and hope to thousands through speaking engagements and media appearances worldwide.”
— Physicians' Untold Stories
How This Book Can Help You
New York, home to the greatest concentration of hospitals and physicians in the nation, from Bellevue to Memorial Sloan Kettering, is a place where the sheer volume of clinical encounters makes the kind of unexplained phenomena Dr. Kolbaba describes in Physicians' Untold Stories statistically inevitable. The intensity of New York medicine—where residents at institutions like NewYork-Presbyterian see more death in a month than many rural doctors see in a year—creates conditions ripe for the extraordinary experiences Dr. Kolbaba, trained at Mayo Clinic and practicing at Northwestern Medicine, has carefully documented from physicians who dare to share what they've witnessed.
The Northeast's medical ethics community near Carmel, Rochester, New York will find in this book a practical challenge: how should ethics committees handle cases where a patient's treatment decisions are influenced by an NDE or a ghostly encounter? These aren't hypothetical scenarios. They happen in real hospitals, and the current ethical frameworks aren't equipped to address them.

Reader Ratings Distribution
Based on 1,018 Goodreads ratings
“One Amazon reviewer wrote: "I shivered. I cried. I read some out loud to the spouse. Please write more."”
— Physicians' Untold Stories
Free Interactive Wellness Tools
Explore our physician-designed assessment tools — free, private, and educational.
Other Neighborhoods in Rochester
Nearby Cities
Explore Other Countries
Related Reading
Frequently Asked Questions

Discover the Stories Medicine Never Says Out Loud
Physicians' Untold Stories by Scott J. Kolbaba, MD — 4.5 stars from 1018 readers.
Order on Amazon →This page contains approximately 1,359 words of unique content.